I watched Fanny: The Right to Rock as it made its #rockdocs debut on American public television.
The 2021 documentary features a band which almost seems fictional. Even with the cliche of “no one remembers”, I had never come across them before.
My first experience was when I was sharing #unheardmusic- bands and albums that o thought more people should hear and a friend of mine brought up Fanny.
Now, in the golden age of social media, they have finally seen their day, with millions of streams but it seems like they were almost destined to be forgotten.
They were the first all girl band to release a major label album and the first all girl band to really have national success.
While their early work was typical rock fare of the time, I find I really enjoy their later stuff as glam was coming into vogue.
The doc was compelling because the story is compelling but I was a bit disappointed in that it felt low budget.
Some online reviews complain about it being “woke” at the end because the women of the band stay politically active. Maybe some things don’t change. Still, I agree that it falls into that rock band doc trap of “what people are really interested in is our new album”.
It is a conundrum and rightfully, I shouldn’t be the one making the film. On one hand, the story of Fanny is a pretty typical rock band story with internal politics and record company meddling. On the other hand, the band are real trailblazers. But in a way, they are trailblazers because they just rocked like any band would. I don’t want a “how long have you been a female musician?” Doc but at the same time it is an amazing story and you want to hear about what their journey was.
I think it would have been better with a narrator, and if not, I would still like more of a focus on the bands history. Grabbing a quick glance at Wikipedia, there are interesting routes there and plenty of interesting cameos along the way that either got little time or skipped altogether.
I loved the guests - Earl Slick and Gail Ann Dorsey of Bowie’s band, true rock historian and Def Lep main man Joe Elliott, band producer Todd Rundgren and a who’s who of female rockers like Bonnie Raitt, Kate Pierson, Cherie Currie, Alice Bag and Kathy Valentine of the Go Gos
In a review for Point of View, Susan Cole laments there is no mention of the Riot Grrl movement.
I get it because essentially Fanny is RiotGrrl a full twenty years before it existed. But I also think it’s proper to say Fanny was important for all female rockers. It’s hard to hear them and not think of Heart. It seems to be important to frame their spot in history, Rock history.
It shocks me that I wasn’t familiar with the band. Sure, they exist in that era of old record albums stuffing crates - bands like Mott the Hoople, Humble Pie, James Gang, Spooky Tooth, Spirit and Wishbone Ash to name a few
And while those bands have slipped off the mainstream, I still feel like those examples are still largely discussed in genre specific media.
Fanny seemed bound for those album stacks. Because of all of their national TV appearances, I know they were popular, but the doc doesn’t really give me much to go on. As the band focuses on the personalities and high level career, I would have to loved to know more about the actual music.
It doesn’t help that the music industry has changed so drastically. The band had a Top 40 single from their second release but consensus is their third album Fanny Hill is probably their commercial and artistic peak. “Ain’t it Peculiar” a top 100 single and currently considered the bands representative single. With engineer work from Geoff Emerick and support from Bobby Keys, that album went to # 135 their high water mark on the album sales chart and is around the time, David Bowie wrote a fan letter to the band.
In todays world, a label might drop a band if they haven’t conquered the world by two records.
On their fourth album, they had changed producers to Todd Rundgren and a harder sound.
On their fifth album, they changed labels to Casablanca (which would be some famous for KISS, Donna Summer and The Village People) and it’s a drastically different band. They have a new producer Vini Poncia who was in between producing Ringo Starr’s biggest hits and going on to work with KISS.
They add Patti Quatro (yes, Suzi’s sister) on guitar and take lead vocals on some songs.
Here’s the thing. The album got mixed reviews and you can definitely hear the record company pressure. It’s not perfect. But it is also the album that gave them their biggest single “Butter Boy” which went to 29 on the US charts.
To my ears, these last two albums are my favorite. Now this is more attuned to my preference than to any other factor. And the kicker is as the song was becoming a success, the band broke up.
Patti is a good sport and participant. It’s got to be hard as the band was originally always the Millington Sisters and Patti was a hired hand go replace guitarist June. Her songs are pretty fantastic to my ears, though
I completely understand why the band doesn’t like the album which is an unwanted makeover, but it has some great moments and really underscores how totally unheralded Quatro is. With her sister, she’s responsible for the Pleasure Seekers “What a way to die” which is as good a Garage Rock song as one can find, written in 1965 Detroit, predating studio recordings by the Stooges, the MC5 and Alice Cooper.
We can’t really say if Fanny would have been bigger. A modern day listener would say five albums in as many years- they were done. But in the 70s, you had bands develop and gain new fans organically. If their last album sounds dated, it also has some songs that seem to be anticipating what the radio was going to play in the upcoming years. The fact is no record company is going to do anything with a defunct band and this literally is a case of breaking up at peak commercial success.
Fanny The Right to Rock is a success in that it sent me to listen to their music and learn more about them. It has helped their presence and they now fit comfortably on satellite radio shows like Little Steven’s Underground Garage. Younger audiences will likely look for their music because of this, which is the goal.
I was left wanting more, but here’s the thing, the music is out there and like anyone who watches, it sent me on a mission to hear the music.
1974 - Casablanca
No comments:
Post a Comment